AUS vs IND: Rohit Sharma or KL Rahul? Who should open for India in the Adelaide Test?



India they will be looking to extend their lead down the stretch Border-Gavaskar Trophy (BGT) 2024-25 as they face Australia at Pink ball test in Adelaide starting December 6. With Rohit Sharma Returning to lead the team after missing the first Test, there could be significant changes in the batting order. KL Rahul and Yashasvi JaiswalHer stellar opening partnership in Perth has added complexity to team selection. Rohit’s recent form and position are the talk of the town and the Indian team management is faced with a crucial decision.

KL Rahul and Yashasvi Jaiswal’s record breaking partnership

Rahul and Jaiswal created history with their opening stand of 201 runs in the first Test, the highest ever by an Indian pair in Australia. Rahul’s calm and composed approach complemented Jaiswal’s aggressive style, forming a perfect partnership to neutralize the Australian pacers. Both batsmen handled the new ball with skill, showing patience and resilience on a difficult Perth wicket.

Jaiswal’s stunning knock of 161 runs showed his ability to dominate even under pressure, while Rahul’s 77 added stability. Their partnership was instrumental in India’s commanding 295-run win. With another solid opening stand of 75 runs in the practice match against the Australian Prime Minister’s XI, they strengthened their case to remain intact at the top.

Rohit Sharma’s Experience and Role for Team India

Rohit’s inclusion brings immense value to the Indian lineup, especially in the absence of experienced middle-order players like Cheteshwar Pujara. Despite his struggles as an opener in recent Tests, Rohit has excelled in the middle-order, averaging 54.57 at No. 6 with three centuries. His adaptability and leadership skills make him a vital cog in the Indian lineup. Rohit’s move to the middle order could provide stability and an experienced hand against Australia’s lethal bowling attack in pink-ball conditions. His contributions to Australia as a middle-order batsman further strengthens his case for a strategic change in the batting order.

READ ALSO: AUS vs IND: Harbhajan Singh explains why Shubman Gill should be left out of Adelaide Test

India’s opening combination for the pink ball Test against Australia

  • Form and consistency in the last matches
    Rohit’s recent performances in Test cricket have raised concerns about his ability to provide consistent starts at the top. Over his last six Test stints, Rohit has amassed only 91 runs, including a solitary half-century, suggesting a lack of pace. In contrast, KL Rahul showed his resilience and adaptability under pressure in the first Test in Perth. His well-made 77, coupled with excellent shot selection and temperament against a strong Australian attack, highlighted his form. Rahul’s consistency in exploiting the starts and berths of the fielders makes him a reliable opener for the pink ball Test.
  • Experience vs. current dynamics in opening partnerships
    While Rohit’s experience as an opener across formats cannot be overlooked—as he has been one of the most successful batsmen in recent years—it is KL Rahul who maintains that momentum. The record 201-run stand between Rahul and Jaiswal in the first Test bolstered India’s top order. This partnership, characterized by mutual understanding and complementary playing styles, showed their ability to wear down Australia’s bowlers early on. Disrupting this combination by reintroducing Rohit at the top could disrupt the pace and balance established in the series opener.
  • Adaptability to different roles and circumstances
    Rohit’s career stats reflect his versatility, particularly in the middle order where he averages an impressive 54.57 in Tests. His experience of batting lower, combined with his ability to play counter-attacking cricket, can be a decisive factor under the unique circumstances of a pink-ball Test. Rohit’s technique and composure against the swinging ball could provide stability and depth to India’s middle order. On the other hand, Rahul has proven his ability to handle the new ball effectively, especially in difficult conditions abroad, ensuring that India get off to a strong start. Keeping Rahul at the top would ensure continuity in the team’s strategy while maximizing Rohit’s utility in the middle order.

READ ALSO: AUS vs IND: 3 reasons why Sam Konstas should be picked for remaining Tests of Border-Gavaskar Trophy 2024-25